Sugar: The Sweet Spot Between Health Villain and Performance Hero
Sugar is often misrepresented as a universal threat, but not all sugars are the same. Natural sugars in whole foods can support health, while too much sugar can disrupt metabolism as do sweeteners. The sports nutrition industry has blurred this distinction - vilifying all sugars to promote ultra-processed, synthetic products. This article reveals the truth behind that narrative
Is sugar bad for you? Yes... but that’s not the full story
For years, sugar has worn the black hat in every health headline going – blamed for everything from obesity and diabetes to poor mood, gut problems and chronic disease.
Shop our award winning natural sports nutrition
But like most mainstream nutrition narratives, the truth is more nuanced, because it’s not just what you eat – it’s when, why, and how it fits into the bigger picture of your performance, health and recovery.
Sugar isn’t the enemy. It’s just a natural, fast-acting carbohydrate. Used well, and in the right form, it can be a powerful, natural ally for athletes and active people. The real question is when is sugar bad for you, and when is sugar actually good for you?
Let’s start with the former.
Why sugar gets a bad name - and when that’s justified
Most sugar in the modern diet is from added sugars in everything from fizzy drinks, and cakes to bread and cooking sauce. Here’s what goes wrong:
Spike, crash, repeat
When you eat sugar – especially on an empty stomach or without physical effort – blood sugar spikes. The body responds by dumping insulin into the bloodstream, which sends your blood sugar crashing back down.
Cue cravings, energy dips, mood swings – and the desire for more sugar.
This rollercoaster doesn’t just damage focus and appetite – over time, it leads to insulin resistance, a precursor to serious conditions like diabetes and heart disease.
Stored as fat - especially if you’re sedentary
If your muscles aren’t crying out for fuel – say, you’re chilling on the sofa – then that sugar has nowhere to go. The body stores it as fat, particularly around the midsection, liver and organs, contributing to weight gain, hormonal disruption and metabolic dysfunction.
Gut damage and inflammation
Too much sugar at the wrong time can trigger inflammation, increase your risk of developing leaky gut and cause a potentially harmful microbial imbalance known as dysbiosis.
But the issue here isn’t really sugar - it’s added sugars foods alongside ultra-processed (UPF) ingredients like maltodextrin or sweeteners like sucralose, both of which are proven to disrupt the microbiome, increase gut permeability and inflame the digestive tract.
A compromised gut doesn’t just mean bloating and discomfort – it also affects nutrient absorption, immune function, mood and motivation.
When sugar is good for you: the performance and recovery sweet spot
Used correctly – and in its natural form – sugar can become a vital tool for performance, recovery and resilience.
Let’s break it down.
Sugar during exercise: smart, strategic fueling
When you’re exercising, your body burns carbohydrates. This is especially true in sessions lasting over an hour. If you don’t replace some of that fuel during the workout, you risk:
- Hitting the wall (a.k.a. bonking)
- Mental fog and poor decision-making
- Muscle breakdown for energy
- A longer recovery window
Here, fast-acting natural sugars help maintain performance, preserve muscle mass, and keep you going strong. The key is that sugar only works in your favour when you’re active – or recovering from activity – and it’s paired with fibre, antioxidants and the natural complexity of real food.
It's also worth mentioning here that regular exercise enhances insulin sensitivity and regulates blood triglycerides. Thus, not only do exercisers need sugar, but they're also far more adept at metabolising it and doing so without the negative side effects experienced in a sedentary population.
Organic coconut sugar in Premium Protein helps repair and replenish muscles after exercise
At 33Fuel, we never use synthetic sugars or UPFs. For example, our Chia Energy Gel is made from just four real-food ingredients for strong, stable energy without crashes or gut trouble. It delivers sugar in the form your body understands – supported by fibre, healthy fats and plant micronutrients.
Sugar after training: fast-track your recovery
After hard training your glycogen stores are depleted. Replacing them quickly helps your body shift from catabolic (breaking down) to anabolic (rebuilding).
When sugar is delivered alongside fibre, protein, and nutrients – like in our Amore Energy Bar – it supports:
- Glycogen synthesis
- Muscle repair
- Stable blood sugar
- Reduced post-workout inflammation
It’s the perfect time for fruit, oats, nuts or a naturally sweetened smoothie. Not a can of cola or a ordinary recovery protein full of sweetener.
Natural sugar vs added sugar: source matters
All sugar is not the same. The sugar in a banana is not the same as the sugar in a fizzy drink. Why?
Because whole foods contain everything that makes sugar usable:
- Fibre slows the release of sugar and prevents insulin spikes
- Antioxidants reduce inflammation
- Micronutrients support the body’s recovery pathways
- Natural enzymes help digestion and absorption
We designed every 33Fuel product to respect this. That’s why our products always combine natural sugars with whole foods packed with fibre, nutrients, vitamins and minerals.
The sweetener problem - and how we do it differently
Sugar has become the enemy across the board which, we now know, isn’t the case. But soft drinks manufacturers have leant into this, replacing sugar with artificial sweeteners and covering the end products in ‘health halos’ with labels like ‘low sugar’, ‘zero sugar’ and so on.
Prebiotic fibre is particularly good, which is why we use organic baobab powder in Rocket Fuel
Sadly almost all sweeteners used in ‘sugar-free’ drinks and sports nutrition severely disrupt glucose metabolism, trigger insulin release, and damage gut health.
Studies have shown:
- Sucralose and Acesulfame-K increase insulin and reduce insulin sensitivity
- Sweeteners disrupt gut bacteria and increase inflammation
- They often increase hunger and cravings later on
At 33Fuel, we never use artificial sweeteners. We use natural sugar and, occasionally, stevia leaf. It’s the only natural sweetener there is that’s actually natural.
So, is sugar bad for you?
As we’ve seen, it can be. Stripped of nutrients, and consumed outside of activity or recovery, sugar can harm your health, your gut, your energy and your long-term performance.
But sugar can also help when it’s timed with training, used during recovery, always paired with real food, and treated like the natural carbohydrate it is.
Sugar is helpful when:
- You’ve trained hard and need to recover
- You’re mid-session and need fuel
- Combined with real ingredients like oats, fruit and nuts
- Part of a long-term health and performance strategy
Sugar is harmful when:
- You’re inactive or eating it out of habit
- Consumed without fibre or nutrients
- It comes from ultra-processed sources
Rethink the way you fuel
At 33Fuel, we’re not anti-sugar. We’re anti-bullsh*t. We believe in real food, strategic fueling, and sports nutrition that works with your body – not against it. That’s why our products are always:
- Free from ultra-processing
- Free from synthetic vitamins, artificial sweeteners and other nonsense ingredients
- Rich in fibre, healthy fats and natural carbs
So next time you hear “sugar is bad for you,” remember it depends on the context.
Fuel smart. Train hard. Recover well. And always keep it real.
More performance boosting content
From the YouTube Channel - Lose weight without starving yourself
From the Blog
UK Sugar Tax: Cutting sugar while UPFs thrive
Post-workout nutrition: 7 golden rules
How to avoid ultra-processed foods
